Dupes for

CarminaCreed

5 verified listings · 3 merchants · checked Aug 20, 2026

Melodia — photograph by ALT Fragrances

Cheapest verified listing

$39.0030 ml · ALT Fragrances

Compare 5 verified listings Search Amazon for the original

No independent reviewer evidence has been collected for this record yet, so this page does not recommend one.

3 shops publish an alternative to Creed Carmina and name it on their own product pages. What follows is what each is asking, and the words each used.

Compare offers

3 merchants · checked Aug 20, 2026

Sizes differ between shops, so compare what a millilitre costs rather than the sticker.

What a millilitre costs

Shorter is better value

ALT Fragrances 60 ml$0.82

Oakcha 50 ml$0.92

ALT Fragrances 30 ml$1.30

The Dua Brand 34 ml$1.62

The Dua Brand 10 ml$2.00

Every verified listing

5 listings

The Poem The Dua Brand10 ml · Out of stock · checked Aug 20, 2026$20.00View

Melodia ALT Fragrances30 ml · checked Aug 20, 2026$39.00View

Rosalina Oakcha50 ml · checked Aug 20, 2026$45.95View

Melodia ALT Fragrances60 ml · checked Aug 20, 2026$49.00View

The Poem The Dua Brand34 ml · checked Aug 20, 2026$55.00View

Prices and stock are what the shop’s own page published on the day beside each row, not a live feed. Every exit is measured; none of them changes what this page concluded.

No samples published by these merchants — some keep those quiet.

What the shops said

5 claims

5 verified exact · 0 mismatches · read off each shop’s own product page, word for word

The PoemThe Dua BrandInspiration: Carmina by Creed (Retail Price: $173)Evidence Aug 20, 2026

MelodiaALT FragrancesInspired by Creed CarminaEvidence Aug 20, 2026

RosalinaOakchaInspired by Creed's CarminaEvidence Aug 20, 2026

MelodiaALT FragrancesInspired by Creed CarminaEvidence Aug 20, 2026

The PoemThe Dua BrandInspiration: Carmina by Creed (Retail Price: $173)Evidence Aug 20, 2026

Scent profile

11 published notes

Floral

Rose de Mai, Violet, Peony

Spicy

Saffron, Pink Pepper

Musky

Cashmere Wood, Musk

Smoky

Frankincense, Myrrh

Fruity

Black Cherry

Amber

What these families mean

Floral: Flower materials — rose, jasmine, iris, orange blossom, tuberose.
Spicy: Warm spice materials — saffron, pepper, cardamom, cinnamon, clove.
Musky: Musks and skin-register materials — ambrette, powder accords, cashmere accords.
Smoky: Smoke, burnt resin, tanned and cured materials — oud, incense, leather, tobacco.
Fruity: Fruit materials, stone fruit and berries — peach, blackcurrant, cherry, fig.
Amber: Resins and balsams — labdanum, benzoin, ambroxan, ambergris accords. Base-register materials.

Published note words, read from Creed’s own page. Colour marks the family a word belongs to — it is never a rating, and nothing on this page says how anything smells.

What the shops list instead — 17 words

Black Cherry, Saffron, Pink Pepper, Rose De Mai, Violet, Cashmere Wood, Peony, Frankincense, Myrrh, Amber, Musk, Nutmeg, Tuberose, Rose, Cherry, Ambroxan, Myrhh.

Both lists are published copy. A shop reprinting the brand’s note list is not independent corroboration of anything, and this page does not treat it as such.

How we verify

Every claim on this page was read off the shop’s own product page and linked back to it with the date we read it. We record the statement the merchant makes; we publish no similarity score and we do not judge how anything smells. Where a shop’s claim turns out to name a different flanker or a different edition, the row says so instead of being quietly dropped. How we verify.

Commissions never change our evidence conclusions, product verdicts, or whether a viable option is shown.

More from Creed

4 more records

$39.00 cheapest5 verified listings, none ranked

Compare 5

Top